Traditional Skills Experiment: Old-Fashioned vs Modern Living

For the past few months, I’ve found myself asking the same question over and over:

Why does modern life often feel so hard?

Not just expensive. Hard. We have grocery stores on every corner. Delivery apps. More gadgets than any generation before us. And yet somehow, many of us still feel like we’re constantly planning meals, losing stuff, re-buying the things we lost, cleaning up messes, and wondering what the heck is going on.

So I’ve been thinking about the way people used to do things. (I’ve always been a history nerd.)

Jennifer Maker in her vintage kitchen corner

Not because I believe the past was better.

And certainly not because I want to romanticize hardship.

But because I keep wondering if we may have thrown away some genuinely useful ideas along the way.

This summer, I want to find out.

My Vintage Summer Experiment

I’m planning a summer series of real-world experiments here at Maker Farm where I test some old-fashioned approaches to home life, storage, food, and cooking to see what actually holds up today.

Questions like:

  • Were there better methods for storing things?
  • Does buying in bulk save money, or does it mostly lead to waste?
  • Is it better to line dry your clothing, or is that just inefficient?
  • Is growing your own vegetables worth the time and effort?
  • Is canning food to eat later doable, or too much work?
  • Are chickens actually a smart way to get eggs, and how difficult is it really?
  • Do old kitchen workflows make cooking easier?
  • Should we make our own clothes, or just buy what we need?
  • Was it better to fix and mend, or is it just not worth it anymore?
  • Were there ways to clean things that actually worked better than what we do now?
  • Which traditional habits genuinely reduce stress, and which ones only sound good in theory?

I’m not interested in nostalgia for the sake of it.

I’m interested in results.

I want to know what actually makes life easier, what saves money, what reduces waste, and what is worth keeping in a modern home.

So I’ll actually be TRYING these things this summer so I can evaluate them. And then sharing the completely-honest results — good or bad or disastrous — with you. No sugar coating the truth.

And I’d love your help.

If you could pick ONE thing you’ve always wondered about – one old-fashioned skill, habit, system, or practice you’ve heard people recommend but never knew whether it was truly worth it – what would it be?

Let me know in the box below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

My Little Vintage Corner

I’m setting up a corner here at my studio to work on my summer experiment and also to share what I learn with you. I’ll still share shots around the farm and studio proper, of course, but this gives me a dedicated spot to chat and share results with you. I got lucky on Facebook Marketplace with a few old cast-offs that I re-homed here to help me test my ideas, like an old cast iron sink with a built-in drainboard (right), an old porcelain-topped table (center), and an old kitchen cabinet with pull-out top (left) — all of which have interesting features I will use. I’d date each one to approximately 90-110 years old. This in itself is an example of mending, rather than buying new, because I had to fix up each one a bit, but it was worth it because they are all good things that do not belong in a landfill.

Here is a shot of what I have in my corner so far, and I’m sure it’ll change as I use it, but even right now I’d love to spend time here. Can you imagine sitting down to some tea and fresh-picked fruit with me at that cute little table?

My Current Traditional Skill In-Progress

An “old-fashioned skill” I’ve been working on a lot on lately is home cooking from scratch, as feeding ourselves is the one thing that happens multiple times a day, so you’ll see me talk about that a lot.

I’ve been cooking a lot and sharing my recipes as I go along. In the past few weeks, I’ve shared TEN new recipes — all super easy, all delicious, and all using basic ingredients and cooking tools most of us have already at home and in our pantries.

Here are my latest recipes:

1
easy goulash recipe bowl
Easy Goulash Recipe
Easy Goulash is a cozy one-pot pasta dinner made with ground beef, tomato paste, diced tomatoes, broth, and elbow macaroni. This version is rich, simple, and family-friendly, with tomato paste adding extra depth and a thicker, heartier sauce. A family favorite!
Check out this recipe
2
Homemade Red Enchilada Sauce in a Mason jar
Red Enchilada Sauce Recipe
This homemade red enchilada sauce is rich, smooth, and full of flavor, yet tastes familiar and comforting. Unlike some homemade versions that can be intensely chili-forward, this recipe balances the spices with tomato sauce for a milder, more rounded flavor that works beautifully in enchiladas, casseroles, soups, and skillet meals. Makes 4 cups.
Check out this recipe
3
Ground beef stroganoff in a white bowl
Ground Beef Stroganoff Recipe
This easy ground beef stroganoff recipe has all the creamy, savory comfort of the boxed version you grew up with, but made from real ingredients and with much better flavor. Tender egg noodles are tossed with seasoned ground beef in a rich sour cream sauce.
Check out this recipe
4
Creamy sausage pasta in a cast-iron-skillet on the stove
Creamy Sausage Pasta Recipe
Creamy sausage penne with a silky parmesan cream sauce, browned Italian sausage, and sweet onions for an easy, cozy dinner.
Check out this recipe
5
Best Shepherd's Pie being dished out of skillet with a wooden spoon
Best Shepherd’s Pie Recipe
A classic homemade shepherd’s pie made with a saucy filling of ground lamb and soft vegetables, and topped with a thick layer of cheesy mashed potatoes baked until golden and bubbling. The ultimate cozy meal!
Check out this recipe
6
Old-fashioned rice pudding in custard cup
Baked Rice Pudding Recipe
An old-fasioned rice pudding that gets its creamy texture on the stovetop before being baked in the oven.
Check out this recipe
7
Blackberry Jam
Blackberry Jam Recipe Without Pectin
This homemade blackberry jam is a simple, small batch recipe that highlights the natural sweetness and slight tartness of ripe blackberries. Made with just fruit, sugar, and a touch of lemon juice, it cooks down into a rich, spreadable jam without needing added pectin.
Check out this recipe
8
Pepper Steak Recipe
Pepper Steak Recipe
A simple, better-than-takeout pepper steak made with thinly sliced flank steak, bell peppers, and pantry staples. The beef stays tender, the peppers keep their bite, and everything is coated in a quick, glossy glaze instead of a watery sauce.
Check out this recipe
9
Sunday Night Beef Stroganoff
One-Pan Beef & Noodles Recipe
A one-pan ground beef meal made with egg noodles cooked directly in a creamy, savory sauce. This version uses simple ingredients and is designed to be dependable, filling, and easy to make at the end of a long day.
Check out this recipe

I hope you’ll try making one.

Perhaps you’ll even consider experimenting along with me? You don’t have to to try ALL the things I try, but pick one that interests you — like more scratch cooking — and give it a try and then report back YOUR findings. You can even let me know here in the comments what you plan to experiment with, as I’d love to know what you’re doing alongside me.

Love,
Jennifer

Jennifer in meadow near studio

Meet Jennifer

Jennifer cooks and experiments in the kitchen at Maker Farm, where she focuses on simple pantry cooking, homemade staples, and practical recipes that make everyday meals easier. Over the years she has tested many ways to make cooking simpler and more dependable, and shares the methods that work best in her own kitchen, occasionally showing them on her Heart to Home at Maker Farm vlog.

Similar Posts

142 Comments

  1. Natural healing herbs for arthritis, stomach upsets and aches and pains in general .

    Looking forward to your reports.

  2. I do not think the wraps are better. I also think the papers that the use on meats freezer burn

  3. I’m interested in growing my own vegetables and wanted to know if Canning is worth the effort.

  4. I love your recipes and can’t wait to try them. I’m a very picky eater and am pleasantly surprised that there is not very many ingredients in the recipes that I don’t like. Looking forward to seeing and trying more.

  5. Were there ways to clean things that actually worked better than what we do now?

  6. it sounds like a very interesting study. I’d like to know the results and what you found out along the way these are all questions that I’ve asked myself.

  7. I want to try your chicken noodle soup recipe. In 70s when I was a new bride and a college student and lived in an old farmhouse I was kind of living my dream. I had a Garden very big garden, canned and froze most of it. I made my curtains and my clothes. Love to do hand work, knitting and crocheting. I’m not sure if it was worth it, but I really didn’t have a choice. I truly felt like I lived a little house in the big woods.
    Now fast-forward to about three years ago. I am in my 70s and was given an instant pot. I made my first homemade chicken noodle soup and it was so good. I really didn’t realize how good it was until I was sick for the last three weeks. I bought a can of chicken noodle soup and was so surprised in the difference. I hadn’t made jelly or juice in years. Last year Leon bought a flat of strawberries and I made jelly. It was awesome. .
    When I see a pantry, which I don’t have now, it is so comforting. I really am anxious to see your responses.

  8. I like mg to do this as well. I think for me the ones that stick out the most are growing and canning/storing our own food. Is it cheaper, healthier and practical.

  9. Hi Jennifer,
    I just received your Vintage Summer Experiment email and I’m so excited to journey along with you!
    All of your ideas are common sense and something that we all need to think about.
    I have my mom’s old Housier style cabinet and love seeing you enjoy yours as much as I enjoy mine.
    I grew up with her cabinet, a cast iron kitchen sink with the draining board much like yours, and refinished an old oak drop leaf table and four chairs much like yours many years ago. I have many fond memories of sitting with my grandad and grandma at their porcelain kitchen table.
    We have made life much more difficult in the last 40 years. Food isn’t as pure, natural, flavorful or healthy and I’ve gone back to making most everything from scratch, which brings me great joy. Canning and preserving is easy and produces much better quality food that’s toxin and preservative free. Making my own butter from my neighbor’s fresh cream is a fun process and so delicious. Her fresh eggs are delicious too.
    Cleaning is more difficult and toxic now than ever before.
    I love the smell and freshness of line dried clothes, flowers from my garden, bread hot out of the oven, and the music from the songbirds!
    I’ve transitioned back to mostly cotton clothes and even linen sheets.
    Sewing and mending has always been enjoyable, but it’s a difficult process to find good fabric nowadays.
    Thrifting and repurposing is fun and exciting as well as economical and I like to refinish beautiful old pieces that are solid wood and much better built than most new furniture available today. There is a certain sense of accomplishment that goes along with fixing and refurbishing.
    I’ve enjoyed watching your blue birds, gardening, building, and seasonal videos and prayed for you as you have rested and healed. Your calming videos are always a blessing to me.
    I could go on, but you probably know by now that I enjoy every one of your videos and applaud you and Greg for sharing your love of life with us.
    Your Vintage Summer Experiment will surely be a hit and I look forward to watching the process unfold as we all learn together. I feel like we’re friends.
    May God richly bless you and your family.

  10. I have been really curious about one of the ideas you have up there, is it worth it to grow vegetables? I know they can be more tasty from personal experience, but it is time and effort. I love all your ideas and will be following along!

  11. I’ve always wondered about chickens! At my house, we have open space with a variety of wild life right behind us, I think the coyotes would eat all our birds if we tried to raise some, but it sounds like a great idea. I’m also curious about gardening… is it really cost effective, especially in climates where we can’t grow all year long? I am excited to see what you decide to try first.

  12. Even though I know how to sew, does it still save money to make your own clothes?

  13. So, my beloved Polish grandma was born in 1902 which means she became a wife & mother during the Great Depression & the Dust Bowl. She always, no matter where they were did 2 things. 1) She had a garden of some sort to grow herbs, simple berries, & basics like lettuce, beets, & other greens AND she had chickens for their eggs & their meat. She also used EVERY PART of the plants she grew & harvested by eating the green tops of the beets (SO GOOD!) along with the bottoms, feeding the lettuce core to the chickens she always kept, etc. 2) She made EVERYTHING when it came to processed foods except hard cheeses. She exchanged eggs & herbs for goat’s milk to drink & to make cheese. She did the same for the cow’s milk that she churned into butter. At harvest time, she bought slabs from butchered pigs & cows which she then broke down & hand ground for hamburger, sausage (I still have her Polish kielbasa recipe that was her mother’s from the homeland), stew meat, pork chops, & a few roasts. Steaks were NEVER on the menu as they were for rich people. What Meme couldn’t make herself or grow, she traded for using her amazing knitting skills, goat cheese making skills, sewing skills, & the sheer force of her tiny yet powerful frame to do other people’s laundry, clean their homes, or muck out a stable. Whatever it took to not have to spend the precious dollars she made as a suddenly single mom when her first husband was killed crossing the street in Chicago — struck by one of Chicago’s big gangster’s vehicles as it gave chase after a rival gangster’s vehicle, tommy guns blazing. Witnesses said that the vehicle never even slowed down after it hit my Meme’s first husband while she was 7 months along with their first child. If I could figure out anything, it would be how my Meme traded for things. Everything today is spend, spend, spend. Then, use a few times & throw away. I’d also love to see if sewing even some of my clothes & my husband’s clothes would lower our financial output. I remember my mom making clothes for all of us; she even made my dad’s ties for work for a number of years! However, that would require me actually being able to sew, figure out patterns, & such. Mom & Dad got me sewing classes as a teen, I tried doing simple patterns for my boy when they were toddlers but I failed again & again. Today, my Cricut pink fabric mats are piled in a corner, completely unused; I am too afraid to even try a simple bowl cozy pattern because sewing just doesn’t appear to be in my wheelhouse — even if it’s just a straight line of simple stitches. LOL! So, what about trading for what we need with neighbors, friends, &, as Meme most often did, our church family? What happened to the close communities we used to have?

  14. We live on 10 acres in a wildfire area in Northern California. Cutting the grass down to the ground around all the outbuildings is a big chore and we use gas- and electric-powered weed-eaters to do the job.

    But I’ve seen some videos of people using scythes. It looks so much more efficient and it would sure be nice to not have to gas up or charge up the devices. But I have questions:
    1. can it be done on a steep slope?
    2. how hard is it to learn to do?
    3. how long before you have to sharpen the blade?
    4. how do you sharpen the blade?

  15. Sunday Lunch or Roast dinner. Before everyone worked on Sundays when Sundays were rest days and grown family came home with their family. Connecting with real life. Playing games like cards or board games with all generations included. Conversations about their week with no devices to be seen not even TV. Respect for life and family. Oh the good old days

  16. I want to know if it’s really worth the time, effort and *money* to grow your own veggies. While YouTube makes it look easy, I’m the person who kills every plant. If your soil isn’t nutrient dense, you will have to buy soil and other things like compost to ensure your veggies will get the nutrients it needs. What about pests? Does companion gardening really work?

  17. Were the foods and diets healthier than what we consume today? its seems like they ate hearty but there wasn’t a problem with obesity like there is now.

  18. I’d love to know how the chicken’s work out please. Thanks

  19. I feel like you are on the right track. I have cooked from scratch for many years. We rarely eat out, because we know what we are eating and try to eat healthier. My husband was recently diagnosed diabetic, so we have researched what is best for him as far as meals go. We have canned our own fruits and veggies for years. Soooo much better. I will be interested in what you are doing this summer. Thank you for sharing this adventure with us.

  20. I think the skill of making clothes – sewing & knitting is mostly lost- due to time, fast fashion & lower cost of mass produced clothing. Even repairing clothing seems like a big challenge. My mum used to knit, but didn’t really pass it down & therefore I haven’t passed any such skills down to my children. Interestingly, my son taught himself to sew.

  21. Canning vegetables: Is it practical to can vegetables today with so many canned and frozen vegetable options today? I remember sitting at the table “snapping” green beans with my mom. She would then work her magic and can them all. They were a part of our special Sunday dinners. Green beans just tasted different back then. I’m sure that was a lot of work for Mom, but she never complained, and it seemed there was no such thing as mental stress. Maybe modern conveniences take away an important part of human necessity: the need to create with our own physical energy, together. Mom lived to be just three months shy of her 100th birthday. Something was working right for her.

  22. I’ve been wondering about canning and how they used to dig root cellars into the ground and if this really is an effective way to store food.

  23. Does canning a large batch of soup, vegetables, fruit save money? Is it more about quality than money savings?

    A friend and I get together and can a huge batch of vegetable soup. It is so awesome in the winter to throw a pot of soup together by adding spices, protein and maybe some broth.

  24. I’ve dabbled a little in canning jellies and jams, but wonder if I shouldn’t try more staples, vegetables and the like, even though there are only two of us in this household.

  25. I believe sewing is a lost art. Is more people would sew And create useful items, It would make life easier.
    Instead of buying clothes, You could mend, Alter And repurpose in item of clothing.
    For storage you can make baskets add a fabric, Cardboard, cereal boxes and other items people throw away.
    My mother always said make your trash small and I live by that today
    After seeing all the trash in the ocean and how it’s affecting our fish and climate. I try to reuse every package I come across.
    On raising chickens, they do take a lot of work and you have to keep up with their waste and feeding. You will get healthier fresher eggs knowing what went in them.
    I think it will be a good project for every day Life all summer long and into the new year.
    Somebody has to cook when we land on Mars!

  26. I love cooking from scratch and baking, since my hubby had his mini stroke, pneumonia and heart problems, I’ve been in my kitchen more cooking and double up on the recipes so always one in the freezer. I’m 77 and still found time to walk the dog, play with the great grandkids, and play my keyboard. Swimming has took a back step at the minute. I’m up earlier and bake while hubby has a well deserved rest. In bed early and sleep better.
    A big thank you Jennifer for all you do. Sending hugs
    Jan xx

  27. We are trying out a new veggie garden this year. Last year was a disaster in our old beds and we got some newer and bigger ones. We shall see how it goes especially since I have a black thumb.

  28. Homeopathy/Natural medicine. Lord please help me out? I’m so overwhelmed with the pain every day 😞. Isn’t there anything else that works? I’m sleeping in the day and awake at night. I’m tired of the morphine 24/7…
    I’d love to move into a cabin in the forest. I know I’d feel better.

  29. I have been interested in buying in bulk, but then I need to know how to store in bulk and not have the food go bad. I’m talking about wheat flour or maybe even wheat berries in an accessible way for a small kitchen and I don’t even know if it’s possible, but I’ve been interested in those types of ideas. I do like to buy in bulk, but I do think it leads to some waste as well.

  30. I’m truly looking forward to this series. Keeping my house truly clean seems so difficult now. Part of it is getting older I suppose, but a grandma’s house was always clean, yet I never saw her clean it. (except after meals) Also kitchen flow. I have things sorted into categories (I naturally do this) yet I still feel scattered in the kitchen. I have a very small house and small kitchen so there are limited storage opportunities in the kitchen itself

  31. One thing I have been trying is using herbs to help with allergies, skin, sleeping… instead of reaching for a OTC pill. There will be times when medicine is needed, but since I have been using herbal tea blends for my stuffy nose, itchy eyes… I have stopped taking a daily allergy pill and feel so much better! I sleep better at night after enjoying a relaxing blend of herbal tea! Our ancestors got along very well using plants to heal, so I am giving it a try!

  32. I’m interested in more natural ways to keep our bodies and home clean—both in products and habits.

  33. Fermenting and canning are things I’ve wanted to do but I’ve always been afraid to try.

    I do have fermenting equipment (air locks, lids, etc.) and have done a bit but I gave up after throwing my ferments away because I guess I don’t trust myself enough.

    I do cook from scratch and avoid processed food. I love seeing new recipes avoiding them.

    Wishing good things for you and yours.

  34. We also have open space here, and many coyotes. Greg is building what we hope is our coyote-proof coop right now, and when he finishes, I’ll share what he’s done. 🙂

  35. I’ve often wondered about making your own dry seasonings and sauces that are in powder form for long term storage, I have made a Alfredo sauce this way but want to know if it’s really worth it in the long run.

  36. Very interested in milling flour for own home use. Not in growing the wheat, rye, oats! So sourcing fresh “berries” becomes an issue. Then adjusting tried and true recipes. Storing and bug, mold, etc. free.
    And cheesemaking, leads to the reality that cottage cheese and cream cheese take a long or longer than making ricotta and ricotta pie! Mozzarella on the other hand, definitely keeping this one – as long as Lisa keeps selling morning fresh milked cows whole milk with the cream to us! Sourcing that trusted milk is tough. We really need our farmers and bees.
    In our home, being reminded, grocery store spices could be fresher. Trust them to carry and enhance flavor. Again, the trusted sources for fresh… . Quantity is still an issue, so buy smaller quantity and share it with son, keeps flavors fresh longer for both of our homes. Chamber vacuum seal.
    Here in the USA, think we have lost sight of “salt”. Recently had to “refresh” the salt and peppercorns. Summer growing season is beginning and fresh needs fresh! And that which lingers in our salt shakers… the difference between sea salt, finishing salt, regional salts, and how they enhance the meals, the breads and rolls, the home canned foods. That is amazing.
    The other thing on our list of discoveries is oils. Along with all of the above, they have been on the trail of sourdough bread making and soft cheeses making. Tried the expensive olive oils from specialty store, found “our preferred”, brand and flavor right on the grocery store shelf! One rustic apricot almond sourdough bread, we wanted to enhance the almond flavor. There, too, found the pretty bottle of golden oil, was very lacking in flavor compared to the tin of almond oil. That said, purpose dictates flavor profile.
    It is eye-opening to discover the flavors we have lost in store buying over home cooking.
    Thank you, Jennifer and Greg, for bringing us along on this discovering.
    Yes, I do appreciate the modern appliances, labor saving, thank you fore-fathers. But some of the old ways really are better and healthier, calmer, peaceful and soul rewarding.

  37. Is growing your own vegetables worth the time and effort? – we are trying to grow our own vegetables, but with recent floods its the 4th time in a row my veggies will not survive.

    Are chickens actually a smart way to get eggs, and how difficult is it really? = I realy hope you will be able to answer this one – thinking of getting myself a few chickens.

    Thank you
    Inge
    Western Cape, South Africa

  38. I love how you continue to grow (expertly, I might add) in so many areas! Good for you and all of your followers!
    Your recipes look yummy, fun and very comforting! Just a note – your Easy Goulash recipe is reminiscent of something that I grew up making and still make… American Chop Suey (I grew up in Southern Maine) I make it by sautéing chopped green and an onion – add ground beef – drain – add a can of condensed tomato soup and a can of crushed tomatoes. Add macaroni noodles – season well with just salt and lots of pepper!
    Thank you for sharing so much!

  39. We didn’t own a gun until my dad saw a gray fox outside the chicken yard.
    Don’t buy Bantams as they were too much trouble.
    My brother would tie up the goats with a rope and then I would
    have to get them because they would eat the rope.
    I tried to milk the cows but didn’t get the cream so my dad
    didn’t have me try again.

  40. Hand washing and line drying most of our clothes with natural detergent. Probably better for the clothes and better for the environment.

  41. I’m interested in which traditional habits genuinely reduce stress, and which ones only sound good in theory.

    Separately, in our family we had meatloaf one night and used the leftover meatloaf for goulash the next night.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Videos