Traditional Skills Experiment: Old-Fashioned vs Modern Living

For the past few months, I’ve found myself asking the same question over and over:

Why does modern life often feel so hard?

Not just expensive. Hard. We have grocery stores on every corner. Delivery apps. More gadgets than any generation before us. And yet somehow, many of us still feel like we’re constantly planning meals, losing stuff, re-buying the things we lost, cleaning up messes, and wondering what the heck is going on.

So I’ve been thinking about the way people used to do things. (I’ve always been a history nerd.)

Jennifer Maker in her vintage kitchen corner

Not because I believe the past was better.

And certainly not because I want to romanticize hardship.

But because I keep wondering if we may have thrown away some genuinely useful ideas along the way.

This summer, I want to find out.

My Vintage Summer Experiment

I’m planning a summer series of real-world experiments here at Maker Farm where I test some old-fashioned approaches to home life, storage, food, and cooking to see what actually holds up today.

Questions like:

  • Were there better methods for storing things?
  • Does buying in bulk save money, or does it mostly lead to waste?
  • Is it better to line dry your clothing, or is that just inefficient?
  • Is growing your own vegetables worth the time and effort?
  • Is canning food to eat later doable, or too much work?
  • Are chickens actually a smart way to get eggs, and how difficult is it really?
  • Do old kitchen workflows make cooking easier?
  • Should we make our own clothes, or just buy what we need?
  • Was it better to fix and mend, or is it just not worth it anymore?
  • Were there ways to clean things that actually worked better than what we do now?
  • Which traditional habits genuinely reduce stress, and which ones only sound good in theory?

I’m not interested in nostalgia for the sake of it.

I’m interested in results.

I want to know what actually makes life easier, what saves money, what reduces waste, and what is worth keeping in a modern home.

So I’ll actually be TRYING these things this summer so I can evaluate them. And then sharing the completely-honest results — good or bad or disastrous — with you. No sugar coating the truth.

And I’d love your help.

If you could pick ONE thing you’ve always wondered about – one old-fashioned skill, habit, system, or practice you’ve heard people recommend but never knew whether it was truly worth it – what would it be?

Let me know in the box below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

My Little Vintage Corner

I’m setting up a corner here at my studio to work on my summer experiment and also to share what I learn with you. I’ll still share shots around the farm and studio proper, of course, but this gives me a dedicated spot to chat and share results with you. I got lucky on Facebook Marketplace with a few old cast-offs that I re-homed here to help me test my ideas, like an old cast iron sink with a built-in drainboard (right), an old porcelain-topped table (center), and an old kitchen cabinet with pull-out top (left) — all of which have interesting features I will use. I’d date each one to approximately 90-110 years old. This in itself is an example of mending, rather than buying new, because I had to fix up each one a bit, but it was worth it because they are all good things that do not belong in a landfill.

Here is a shot of what I have in my corner so far, and I’m sure it’ll change as I use it, but even right now I’d love to spend time here. Can you imagine sitting down to some tea and fresh-picked fruit with me at that cute little table?

Jennifer's vintage corner in her studio on Maker Farm

My Current Traditional Skill In-Progress

An “old-fashioned skill” I’ve been working on a lot on lately is home cooking from scratch, as feeding ourselves is the one thing that happens multiple times a day, so you’ll see me talk about that a lot.

I’ve been cooking a lot and sharing my recipes as I go along. In the past few weeks, I’ve shared TEN new recipes — all super easy, all delicious, and all using basic ingredients and cooking tools most of us have already at home and in our pantries.

Here are my latest recipes:

1
easy goulash recipe bowl
Easy Goulash Recipe
Easy Goulash is a cozy one-pot pasta dinner made with ground beef, tomato paste, diced tomatoes, broth, and elbow macaroni. This version is rich, simple, and family-friendly, with tomato paste adding extra depth and a thicker, heartier sauce. A family favorite!
Check out this recipe
2
Homemade Red Enchilada Sauce in a Mason jar
Red Enchilada Sauce Recipe
This homemade red enchilada sauce is rich, smooth, and full of flavor, yet tastes familiar and comforting. Unlike some homemade versions that can be intensely chili-forward, this recipe balances the spices with tomato sauce for a milder, more rounded flavor that works beautifully in enchiladas, casseroles, soups, and skillet meals. Makes 4 cups.
Check out this recipe
3
Ground beef stroganoff in a white bowl
Ground Beef Stroganoff Recipe
This easy ground beef stroganoff recipe has all the creamy, savory comfort of the boxed version you grew up with, but made from real ingredients and with much better flavor. Tender egg noodles are tossed with seasoned ground beef in a rich sour cream sauce.
Check out this recipe
4
Creamy sausage pasta in a cast-iron-skillet on the stove
Creamy Sausage Pasta Recipe
Creamy sausage penne with a silky parmesan cream sauce, browned Italian sausage, and sweet onions for an easy, cozy dinner.
Check out this recipe
5
Best Shepherd's Pie being dished out of skillet with a wooden spoon
Best Shepherd’s Pie Recipe
A classic homemade shepherd’s pie made with a saucy filling of ground lamb and soft vegetables, and topped with a thick layer of cheesy mashed potatoes baked until golden and bubbling. The ultimate cozy meal!
Check out this recipe
6
Old-fashioned rice pudding in custard cup
Baked Rice Pudding Recipe
An old-fasioned rice pudding that gets its creamy texture on the stovetop before being baked in the oven.
Check out this recipe
7
Blackberry Jam
Blackberry Jam Recipe Without Pectin
This homemade blackberry jam is a simple, small batch recipe that highlights the natural sweetness and slight tartness of ripe blackberries. Made with just fruit, sugar, and a touch of lemon juice, it cooks down into a rich, spreadable jam without needing added pectin.
Check out this recipe
8
Pepper Steak Recipe
Pepper Steak Recipe
A simple, better-than-takeout pepper steak made with thinly sliced flank steak, bell peppers, and pantry staples. The beef stays tender, the peppers keep their bite, and everything is coated in a quick, glossy glaze instead of a watery sauce.
Check out this recipe
9
Closeup of beef and noodles
One-Pan Beef & Noodles Recipe
A one-pan ground beef meal made with egg noodles cooked directly in a creamy, savory sauce. This version uses simple ingredients and is designed to be dependable, filling, and easy to make at the end of a long day.
Check out this recipe

I hope you’ll try making one.

Perhaps you’ll even consider experimenting along with me? You don’t have to to try ALL the things I try, but pick one that interests you — like more scratch cooking — and give it a try and then report back YOUR findings. You can even let me know here in the comments what you plan to experiment with, as I’d love to know what you’re doing alongside me.

Love,
Jennifer

Jennifer in meadow near studio

Meet Jennifer

Jennifer cooks and experiments in the kitchen at Maker Farm, where she focuses on simple pantry cooking, homemade staples, and practical recipes that make everyday meals easier. Over the years she has tested many ways to make cooking simpler and more dependable, and shares the methods that work best in her own kitchen, occasionally showing them on her Heart to Home at Maker Farm vlog.

190 Comments

  1. I would like to know how to save seeds and if it’s really worth it.

  2. Is growing your own vegetables worth the time and effort?
    My husband puts out a huge garden. I do all the canning, freezing, etc of all the food it produces.
    But there is only two of us. Is it really worth it? Of course, some does taste better, but…
    I would love to see your results!!

  3. Actually, I have been making my own laundry soap and dish soap for years. I figure it takes less time to make it than it does to find it at the store and it is significantly cheaper and uses ingredients that have been around for years and years.

  4. Not sure if this is what you mean, but I’ve always wondered what difference it makes whether you sift flour or not before it’s added to a recipe.
    I’m looking forward to hearing all about your summer experiment! Good luck!

  5. I try to cook from scratch as much as I can, especially sauces and dressings. I don’t think we need packet mixes for making. I want to know what goes into what I cook.

  6. Is it really cheaper to make your own butter from cream and how long does it last?
    If you have a deep basement that stays really cool, can you store vegetables and fruits down there?

  7. This is Veronica. I wonder about plastics in food and our environment. Did using cast iron skillets work better for us than the non stick pans we use today. Healthier or not?

  8. I’ve also been thinking a lot about plastics, and I’ve been trying to limit my exposure this year. But, my goodness, plastic is everywhere!

  9. I wonder if growing your own vegetables is really cheaper than buying them. I have started planting my own container vegetable garden and it has been very expensive so far. I am new to this so maybe I am doing something the hard way? I would like to grow all of our vegetable that we usually use. So is it more economical to grow or to buy?

  10. I’ve always wondered if growing a vegetable/fruit garden is worth the cost of seed, fertilizer, time, effort. cost of water and ways of preserving any results. can it really save my body and stress.

  11. I am having a hard time with potatoes going bad before I can finish them. I leave them on the counter in a basket, they shrivel up. I tried putting them in the produce bin in the fridge, they still shrivel up. Being in Az we don’t have root cellars. So, was there another way they stored potatoes? Or is it that they already are old from the store. I have been watching homesteaders store their potato crop in a root cellar which last till the next planting season. Why does a small bag of potatoes not stay good?

  12. I want to know if old cleaning supplies and methods work better than today’s.

  13. I’ve often wondered of our ancestors ever did freeze drying from their gardens without just the basic oven or do you have to buy a freeze dry machine ?
    I have a dehydrator but find some of the fruit hard or rubberized .
    I’ve made guide leather but not close to the store bought lol 😂

  14. I’m interested in learning how to canned foods and is it worth it? I love this whole idea!

  15. Canning tomatoes if you cannot grow them yourself. Buying tomatoes at the store or a farmers market, is it worth it?

  16. Is it really healthier and less expensive to make all of my own mixes and convenience foods?

  17. Couldn’t pick only one.

    Is growing your own vegetables worth the time and effort?
    Were there ways to clean things that actually worked better than what we do now? (without the toxins)
    Which traditional habits genuinely reduce stress, and which ones only sound good in theory?

  18. I made the Ground Beef Stroganoff. My husband and grandson liked it but I wasn’t a fan of it. I don’t care much for Sour Cream. It was easy to make and didn’t take as long as I thought it would. If I make it again, I would put all the little ingredients (Paprika, Worcestershire sauce, salt, pepper etc) in dishes. I have small glass dishes that are perfect for these ingredients.

  19. I printed off several of these recipes. They reminded me of some of my favorite childhood meals. I plan to make them soon! I love a meal where I get left overs saving me making a new meal every night after work.

  20. Is growing your own food/vegs really worth it? Especially if you don’t have a freeze-dryer or large-scale dehydrator for preservation. I seem to spend more $$ on the supplies (seeds, plants, water, fertilizer, pots/planters/soil prep, etc) than if I just buy at the grocery store. Not to mention all the work. Thanks, Jennifer.

  21. Jennifer,
    Thank you so much for all the great recipes, some I haven’t thought about for years.
    Here is one you may be able to find. My mother (back in the 60’s) did alot of canning everything from pears to tomatoes and even some sauces. One thing she use to can were plums, the small one with the yellowish color pit. From that she would cook them up and add it to egg noodles as a side dish.
    Would you happen to have a recipe like that in your arsenal?

  22. HI Jennifer, I have been watching you for years- ever since I invested in my first Cricut- that now sits in my husbands craft room-(he makes his own fishing lures and crafts his own stencils) the I just cant seem to connect the computer to the Cricut in my mind.

    However your home post have been welcoming. I live in Akron Ohio, just south of Cleveland. I’ve been thru Ann Arbor- beautiful country. I am a homesteader, and make all my meals from scratch. I do like your meals ideas. however (back to the husband :)) he’s gluten-free. So I have to adapt. Also I prayed for you as you went through your minor (major) health situation. I’m glad you are enjoying life now at a slower pace.

  23. Boiling eucalyptus leave to release the steam will sanitize your whole house and even get into the curtains.

  24. When my kids were little and fussy at dinner time I started making dinner in the morning. By the end of the day everyone was tired and trying to chop, cook and stir just became a lot. Then the kids got older and on Sundays I found myself with my menues for the week and I would chop all of the veggies and pack them together for each meal. I found that there was less waste too. Then when you came in from practice all you had to do was stir fry or bake and in 15-20 minutes dinner was ready. I love using my instant pot for rice so I will make up 4 batches of brown rice and freeze the other 3. Now that I’m older I find that I don’t feel much like cooking at the end of the day so I’m back to making as much of dinner in the morning so I just have to put everything together at the end of the day. It helps us to stay healthy with making good dinners and cheaper than grabbing something ready made with maybe things in it (salt) that we don’t need. When I get a cooked whole chicken from the store on a busy night we will have the breast one night and then chicken enchiliadas (I’ll make your recipe next time) then I put all the bones in the instant pot with some onions, celery and carrots and make bone broth and then I get the bits and pieces together for a feast for a stay cat that comes around….So I don’t think that there could be anything else I could have made and all with a $9 (organic) cooked whole chicken! Can’t wait to see what you come up with for the summer.

  25. Had to chuckle about the scythe remark in your email. I have one from my grandparent’s farm. It does need to be sharpened, though. I remember using it as a kid to tidy up areas that the old no motor lawn mower (which my brother still uses) did not reach.

  26. I have followed you for quite some time. I love all your craft tips, ebooks and videos. I am an Advance member. I am also enjoying seeing your amazing farmhouse and reading about your back to basics cooking style. My only (slight) critique is your recipes are less healthy than I how I eat. I have been able to modify many of your recipes using plant-based foods and less or no butter/oil to fit my lifestyle (my son is vegetarian and I am vegan). I am not expecting you to change your recipes, just voicing my thoughts. Thank you for all you do Jennifer! ❤️❤️❤️

  27. Thank you for the feedback! I realized pretty early on that it would not be possible to make recipes for all types and ways of eating, so I’m sticking with what we’re eating now. We are in a transition period from an over-reliance on pre-made food to 100% home cooking, so I’m prioritizing familiar and “comfort foods” to increase our confidence that we can eat whole foods for less money and better flavor at home. Once that transition is complete (which it almost is, actually), I’ll likely start experimenting with different types of food. So this will evolve over time, as all things do. What you’re doing — using plant-based foods and less or no oil — is exactly what I would have advised, so I am glad that is working.

  28. I often wonder if canning is better? Whether it’s jams fruits or vegetables

  29. It’s about buying in bulk. Seems a waste of money. In Florida we have nowhere to store stuff.

  30. A lot of your recipes feature Pasta, so how about making your own, rather than ‘I assume’ dried out of a packet?

    One thing you will need to take into account is seasonality. A tomato can be bought from your local store anytime of the year, but if you grow your own, assuming they survive the various diseases, then you will only have a crop at a certain time.

  31. Interesting about the gardening and canning. 35 years ago, I did all of that; I lived in OH where the soil was fertile and rain was a regular thing. Now I live in CO in an area referred to as “high desert”. The soil is mostly rock and clay, with little to no summer moisture and excessive heat. I still try to grow things in garden boxes. We pay for water here so that is a cost added to the price of attempting to garden, not to mention buying fertile soil for the garden boxes, so for a very small return (actually edible vegetables), buying is more cost effective, especially at the weekly farmers markets.

  32. I live in AZ, in the Sonoran Desert. So my canning, etc., had a slightly different flavor (pun intended). This week I made prickly pear jelly, ice cream, margaritas, and candy. I’m giving up on that last one–I’ve tried so many recipes and all have been disasters. I also made Palo Verde blossom jelly, mesquite flour, and mesquite bean ice cream. I think that’s my favorite! Soon the saguaro fruit will be ready to harvest. I’ll prepare the juice for jelly making this fall, along with mesquite jelly, and then dry the seeds for using in recipes and grinding into flour. Coming from the Midwest, it’s been fun experimenting with different things these last few years!

  33. I have made egg noodles when I ran out of them in the pantry and that worked out great. I haven’t tried the other pastas yet, but hope to soon.

    As for tomatoes, you can actually freeze them. I still have tomatoes left in my freezer from last year’s harvest, and I still use them — I just used them to make some AMAZING spaghetti sauce the other day. So then as long as you have access to a freezer, you can keep many of your harvests available until you can grow more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Videos